Eastern vs Western vs Southern Caribbean Cruises: What’s the Difference?

Imagine a perfect tropical island. Does it include lush volcanic peaks rising dramatically above the sea? Or maybe a palm-fringed beach with crystal-clear water? Whatever your ideal island escape looks like, you are likely to find it in the Caribbean. The warm waters are host to some 7,000 different islands belonging to 28 nations, many of which are considered the best Caribbean cruise destinations for travelers seeking beaches and adventure. It is a varied lot in terms of topography — and culturally, too, with Americans, Dutch, English, French and Spanish, among others, having left their marks on this sun-kissed corner of the world. Now it’s your turn to explore it. But where should you go? If you’re deciding between an Eastern vs Western vs Southern Caribbean cruise, each region offers different islands, cultures and experiences. Read on to find out which one is right for you.
Rest assured, however, that nearly all of our Caribbean cruises include a call at RelaxAway, Half Moon Cay™, our award-winning private Bahamian island. This quaint sanctuary features new enhancements, including a new Beach Club, tranquil lounges, and exclusive flavors.
Key Takeaways: Eastern vs Western vs Southern Caribbean Cruise
- Each Caribbean cruise region offers a different experience, from beach-focused Eastern itineraries to adventure-heavy Western routes and culturally rich Southern islands.
- Eastern Caribbean cruises typically visit islands closer together, making them ideal for shorter itineraries with fewer sea days.
- Western Caribbean cruises are known for outdoor excursions, including Mayan ruins, waterfalls and snorkeling destinations.
- Southern Caribbean cruises often travel farther south, visiting unique islands like Aruba, Curaçao, and Barbados.
- Choosing between an Eastern vs Western vs Southern Caribbean cruise depends on your travel style, preferred ports and how many sea days you want.
Eastern Caribbean Cruises: Beaches, Culture, and Easy Island Hopping
Whatever eastern Caribbean cruise itinerary you choose, sun-soaked relaxation is in the cards, which is why many travelers consider this region one of the best Caribbean cruise itinerary options for first-time cruisers. The islands of the eastern Caribbean are in relatively close proximity, so you can wake up every day at a new destination. Ports often include San Juan, Puerto Rico; St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands; Amber Cove, Dominican Republic; and Nassau, Bahamas. Amble atop a 17th-century fortress in Puerto Rico or kayak a sparkling bioluminescent bay. Cruise to Turks and Caicos to comb white sand beaches while the sea-breeze tangles your hair. Whichever cruise you choose, in the eastern Caribbean the promise of paradise awaits.

Western Caribbean Cruises: Adventure and Mayan History
Western Caribbean itineraries are known for outdoor adventure. Relax and soak up the sun or embark on a thrilling, can’t-do-anywhere-else excursion that you’ll remember forever. Sail on a catamaran and snorkel at Bonaire Marine Park or take a hike up Dunn’s River Falls. Go under the surface in a submarine off Grand Cayman to see rare marine life or head to the archaeological site of Mayan Tulum from Cozumel. The best time to visit the Western isles on a cruise is between December through April, when the weather is perfect and there’s very little rain. Because the western Caribbean islands are a bit further apart, a cruise in this region usually offers a few sea days to enjoy onboard activities.
Ready to experience the Caribbean’s blissful beaches? Find a cruise now.
Southern Caribbean Cruises: Longer Itineraries and Unique Islands
If you’re deciding on a southern Caribbean vs eastern Caribbean cruise, the southern routes typically travel farther into the Lesser Antilles and visit more diverse islands. Travel to jungled islands, turquoise seas and flaxen beaches on southern Caribbean cruises where the laid-back vibes of the islands reign supreme. After a call at Half Moon Cay, southern Caribbean itineraries dive deeper to explore the Lesser Antilles. There you’ll find European charm in the tropics. From French Martinique to British Barbados, to the Dutch-tinted ABC Islands of Aruba, Bonaire and Curaçao, the influence of the European colonial area is strong, but the islands maintain their natural beauty. Snorkel Aruba’s famous Natural Pool in Arikok National Park or explore Monkeyland at Amber Cove, home to a lively community of squirrel monkeys. Southern Caribbean cruises are typically longer in duration, starting at 9 days. Let the sea carry you to Grenada, St. Vincent & the Grenadines, Dominica, St. Lucia, Martinique and more.

Short Caribbean Cruises and Tropical Getaways
Tropical Caribbean cruises are ideal as a family cruise or a romantic adventure. Swaying palm trees and shimmering waters are ubiquitous in these parts, with calls at Amber Cove, Turks & Caicos, Nassau and beyond. Discover an oasis of aquamarine seas with a vibrant underwater world, perfect for those who like to snorkel, dive and explore. Visit Key West’s popular Butterfly Conservatory and Aquarium or slide down natural waterslides at the waterfalls of Rio de Damajagua in Amber Cove.
Which Caribbean Cruise is right for you?
Choose an Eastern Caribbean cruise if you want:
- Beautiful beaches
- Historic towns like San Juan
- More ports close together
Choose a Western Caribbean cruise if you want:
- Adventure excursions
- Mayan ruins
- Jungle landscapes
Choose a Southern Caribbean cruise if you want:
- More unique islands
- European-influenced culture
- Longer itineraries
When choosing between an Eastern vs Western vs Southern Caribbean cruise, the best option depends on your travel style. Eastern itineraries focus on beaches and historic towns, Western cruises emphasize adventure and Mayan ruins, and Southern routes explore more remote islands like Aruba and Curaçao.
Browse Holland America Line Caribbean cruises to find the itinerary that matches your perfect island escape.
FAQs
What is the difference between Eastern, Western and Southern Caribbean cruises?
The main difference between an Eastern vs Western vs Southern Caribbean cruise is the destinations visited. Eastern itineraries focus on islands like St. Thomas and Puerto Rico, Western cruises visit ports such as Cozumel and Jamaica, while Southern cruises travel farther south to islands like Aruba and Barbados.
Which Caribbean cruise is best for first-time cruisers?
Many first-time travelers choose an Eastern Caribbean cruise because the islands are closer together, itineraries are shorter and ports like Nassau, San Juan, and St. Thomas are easy to explore.
Are Southern Caribbean cruises longer?
Yes, Southern Caribbean cruises are often longer, starting at 9 days in duration because the islands are farther south.
Which Caribbean cruise has the best beaches?
All Caribbean regions offer beautiful beaches, but Eastern Caribbean cruises are especially known for white-sand beaches and turquoise waters in destinations like the U.S. Virgin Islands and the Bahamas.
Which Caribbean cruise is best for adventure activities?
If you enjoy outdoor activities, a Western Caribbean cruise is often the best choice, with excursions like exploring Mayan ruins, hiking waterfalls, and snorkeling along coral reefs.





Hello – anyone reading comments? This is another follow-up request (others ignored?) for anything more definitive on release of 2024 Caribbean cruises. Still in August – if so, when? If not August, than when?
Julie: I’ve submitted a couple Comments since the first of the month. I assume they’re undergoing moderation? Or, is there some other reason for delay?
Just got off the phone with Reservations – checking on a more definite date for 2024 Caribbean cruises. Based on Julies reply above expected some time this month. Your agent said, “Check back in September or October”. Why the delay? Other cruise lines have had their early 2024 Caribbean cruises out for weeks-to-months. You’ve had your early 2024 Asia, Australia/NZ, and South America cruises out for weeks-to-months. What’s the problem? Should I be concerned that HAL is having issues and my 2023 cruises may be at risk?
Coming up on mid-August, still no 2024 Caribbean cruises. Anything more up-to-date on release date?
We’re about of a third of the way into August and not seeing early 2024 Caribbean posted yet. Any update as to when these cruises will post, or if the release date has been pushed back?
Thank you. I’ll keep my eyes peeled
When will the 2024 Caribbean cruises post?
When will the 2024 Caribbean cruises go on sale? Other cruise lines (RCL, NCL, Carnival) already posted.
Interested in an early 2024 Southern Caribbean cruise. Several other lines (RCL, Carnival, NCL) have posted their early 2024 Caribbean cruises already. When will HAL release their’s?